Celebrity culture often interprets professional camaraderie as romantic entanglement. During the worldwide press tour for Prey, Midthunder appeared alongside co-stars Dakota Beavers and Dane DiLiegro at numerous photo calls, comic conventions, and guild screenings. Online commentary quickly generated romance rumors, matching Midthunder with various colleagues. In practice, these appearances were standard professional collaborations. Photographers documented an ensemble cast celebrating a surprise streaming smash, not romantic partnerships.
The actress has frequently used red carpet opportunities to elevate Indigenous fashion and cultural awareness rather than stage romantic narratives. An enrolled tribal member of the Fort Peck Assiniboine and Sioux Tribe, Midthunder routinely platforms Native designers, jewelry artisans, and styling teams at ceremonies like the Critics' Choice Awards. By centering her red carpet appearances on community representation and sartorial storytelling, she redirects tabloid interest toward meaningful artistic dialogue.